Français
Buying

How much is my car worth? Getting a fair trade-in value

Trade-in value, private sale price, free tools to estimate it and the tax advantage of trading in your vehicle in Quebec. How to know what your vehicle is really worth before you go to the dealership.

, Sales ManagerPublished 5 min read
Silver compact car with a blank price tag hanging from the rear-view mirror

You're changing cars and wondering how much yours is worth. Good news: in a few minutes and for free, you can get a solid estimate. But you need to know which "value" you're talking about, because the same car doesn't fetch the same price whether you sell it to a private buyer or trade it in at a dealership.

The short answer

  1. Estimate the value of your vehicle with two or three free tools (CARFAX Canada, AutoHebdo, CarGurus), entering the exact mileage and your postal code.

  2. Expect the trade-in value to be lower than the private sale price: the dealer has to inspect, recondition and resell the vehicle.

  3. Factor in taxes: in Quebec, a trade-in reduces the GST and QST on your new car by about 15% of the value you're given. That's often what makes trading in worthwhile.

The three values of the same car

Value

What it is

Level

Trade-in value

What a dealer gives you toward the purchase of a vehicle

Lowest

Private sale price

What a private buyer is willing to pay you

Higher

Retail price

What a dealer asks when reselling the vehicle

Highest

The gap between trade-in value and retail price covers inspection, reconditioning, the warranty offered to the next buyer, time in inventory and the dealer's margin. CARFAX Canada points this out too: a dealer's offer takes reconditioning costs into account.

Tools to estimate the value

  • CARFAX Canada: a free tool that gives you a value range in a few minutes, based on prices actually paid and adjusted for mileage and region. The full history report, however, costs money.

  • AutoHebdo.net (the Quebec counterpart of AutoTrader.ca): offers a free online appraisal and lets you receive offers from dealers, confirmed after the vehicle is inspected.

  • CarGurus: a free estimate based on listings in the Canadian market.

  • CAA-Québec: a list price estimate offered free to members, by phone or online. These values assume a vehicle in perfect condition.

  • Industry guides, such as the Canadian Black Book: used by dealers to set trade-in and wholesale values. Its website also offers the public an online trade-in value tool for vehicles from the last 13 model years.

Use at least two. If the results are very different, check that you entered the right trim, the right options and the right mileage.

What raises or lowers the value

  • Mileage: the biggest factor after age.

  • Condition: body, rust, interior, tires, windshield.

  • History: reported accidents, number of owners, documented maintenance.

  • Trim and options: a high-end trim or all-wheel drive resells better in Quebec.

  • Demand: a compact SUV or a pickup truck sells faster than a sedan few people are looking for.

  • Season: all-wheel-drive vehicles are more sought after as winter approaches.

How to get the best trade-in value

  1. Clean the car, inside and out. It's the cheapest way to make a good impression.

  2. Gather your maintenance receipts: they prove the vehicle has been looked after.

  3. Fix small, inexpensive defects (a bulb, wiper blades), but don't put money into major repairs right before the trade-in: you rarely get it back.

  4. Have both keys and the owner's manual.

  5. Negotiate the trade-in separately from the price of the new car. Otherwise, a dealer can give you more for the trade-in and a smaller discount on the new car, or the reverse, without you coming out ahead.

  6. Get more than one offer: trade-in value varies from one dealer to another.

The tax advantage of trading in, in Quebec

When an individual trades in their vehicle at a dealership, the GST and QST on the car being purchased are calculated on the price minus the value given for the trade-in.

Hypothetical example: you buy a $40,000 car and your trade-in is worth $15,000. Taxes are calculated on $25,000 instead of $40,000, which saves you about $2,250 ($15,000 × 14.975%).

To benefit, you must own the vehicle you're trading in. The contract must show the amount given for the trade-in and the basis used to calculate taxes.

That's why a trade-in offer a little lower than a private sale price can leave you with just as much money in your pocket in the end, without the hassle of selling.

What if the dealer doesn't want your vehicle?

They can do an accommodation sale: they act as an intermediary to sell your old vehicle to someone else. According to Revenu Québec, you still get the benefit of paying taxes on the difference.

Selling it yourself: what you need to know

Selling to a private buyer often gets you more, but it takes time: listings, viewings, test drives, negotiation. On the tax side, the buyer pays the QST to the SAAQ at the time of transfer, on the higher of the selling price and the vehicle's estimated value. That estimated value is the average wholesale price in the Guide d'évaluation Hebdo, minus $500. There is no GST between private individuals.

If your vehicle is still financed, the loan must be paid off before or at the time of the sale. The Office de la protection du consommateur (Quebec's consumer protection office) also advises buyers to check the Register of Personal and Movable Real Rights (RPMRR) to make sure no debt is attached to the vehicle.

Watch out for negative equity

If you owe more on your loan than your vehicle is worth, the gap is called negative equity. Some financing deals add it to the loan on the new car: you then pay interest on a car you no longer have. Always ask to see this amount separately, and think it over before rolling it into a new long-term loan.

Frequently asked questions

How can I find out what my car is worth for free?

The tools from CARFAX Canada, AutoHebdo and CarGurus are free. Enter the year, model, trim, mileage and your postal code, then compare the results.

What is the Black Book?

The Canadian Black Book is a reference guide to used vehicle values, used by dealers and financial institutions. Its trade-in and wholesale values are lower than private sale prices.

Is it better to trade in your car or sell it yourself?

Selling it yourself often gets you more, but a trade-in saves you taxes and the hassle. Compare the estimated private sale price with the trade-in value plus the tax savings.

What is the "argus"?

It's the term used in France for a used vehicle's rated value. In Quebec, people talk about trade-in value, list price or Black Book value instead.

Get your trade-in appraised along with your offers

Once it launches in Quebec, bolyd will let you enter your trade-in when you describe the car you want. Dealers will take it into account in their offers, and you'll compare the net amount of each offer, trade-in included.

To learn how to compare these offers, read our guide How to compare dealer offers.

bolyd is coming soon to Quebec

Describe the vehicle you want and get offers from dealers. Leave your email to hear when we open.

Do you sell vehicles?Discover bolyd for dealers