Lease or buy a car: how to choose
Lower payment or a car of your own? The right choice depends mostly on your mileage and how long you keep your vehicles. Comparison table, worked example and pitfalls to avoid.

Lease, finance or pay cash: it is often the first question when you shop for a new car. There is no universal answer, but there is a right answer for your situation. It depends mostly on three things: how many kilometres you drive, how long you keep your cars, and what you want to pay each month.
The short answer
Lease if you drive little, like to change cars every three or four years and want the lowest possible payment.
Buy (cash or financed) if you keep your cars a long time, drive a lot or want to drive without a payment someday.
Either way, compare the total cost, never just the monthly payment.
What is the difference?
Leasing means paying to use a car for a fixed period, often 36 to 60 months. You mainly pay for the vehicle's loss in value over that period, plus interest. At the end, you return the car, or you buy it at the price set in the contract (the residual value).
Buying means paying the full price of the car, all at once or with a loan. Once the loan is paid off, the car is yours and you pay nothing more, except maintenance and insurance.
Comparison table
Criterion | Lease | Financed purchase | Cash purchase |
|---|---|---|---|
Monthly payment | Lowest | Higher | None |
Owner at the end | No, unless you buy it out | Yes | Yes |
Mileage limit | Yes, with charges if exceeded | No | No |
Wear and small dents | Can be charged on return | Your call | Your call |
Changing cars often | Easy | Less simple | Less simple |
Cost over 8 to 10 years | Generally higher | Lower | Lowest |
Warranty for the whole term | Often, yes | Not after a few years | Not after a few years |
When leasing is the better choice
Leasing makes sense if:
you drive little and predictably, below the annual mileage set in the contract;
you change cars often, because you like to or to always have the latest safety technology;
you want to stay under warranty for the whole time you use the car;
you want a low payment for a vehicle that would otherwise be out of your budget;
you use the vehicle for your business, which can have tax advantages (check with your accountant).
When buying is the better choice
Buying makes sense if:
you keep your cars a long time: after the last payment, every year without a payment lowers your average cost;
you drive a lot: with a lease, extra kilometres are expensive on return;
you are hard on your vehicles (job sites, dirt roads, pets): you will not be charged for wear;
you want to modify the car (trailer hitch, accessories), which a lease contract often restricts.
An example to compare
Fictional example, for a $40,000 compact SUV before taxes, at the same 5.99% rate:
48-month lease | 72-month financing | |
|---|---|---|
Expected residual value | $20,000 | None |
Approximate monthly payment before taxes | $569 | $663 |
Total payments, before taxes | $27,330 | $47,720 |
At the end | You return the car or buy it for $20,000 | The car is yours |
Leasing looks much cheaper, but at the end, you have no car. If you buy it out after 48 months, you will have paid about $47,330 in total, roughly the same as financing, not counting interest if you borrow to buy it out. On the other hand, if you change cars every four years anyway, leasing saves you from reselling a used vehicle.
These figures are approximations: every contract has its own rate, residual value and fees. Always ask for the total cost in writing.
Taxes: an often-overlooked difference
With a lease, GST and QST apply to each payment, as well as to any amount paid at the end of the contract. When you buy, they apply to the total price of the vehicle. If you buy the car out at the end of the lease, GST and QST also apply to the buyout price.
In both cases, a trade-in reduces the taxable amount: with a lease, it lowers the payments, and therefore the taxes on each one.
What a lease contract must include in Quebec
The Consumer Protection Act closely regulates leases of four months or more. What you need to know before signing:
The purchase option: the contract must state the buyout price, or how it is calculated.
Mileage: charges for extra kilometres can only be required if the cost per kilometre is written in the contract.
Normal wear: the lessor cannot require the car to be returned in better condition than normal wear, nor define normal wear itself in the contract. Nor can it charge you fees because maintenance was done somewhere other than the manufacturer, or with non-original parts.
The inspection before return: for contracts signed since April 5, 2024, the lessor must offer you a free inspection at least 90 days before the end. If you accept, it takes place 30 to 60 days before the end and you receive a written report, which gives you time to have repairs done before the return. On return, if the lessor considers the wear abnormal, it must give you a written notice, and you have 10 days to have the repairs done yourself. Without this inspection offer, it cannot charge you for abnormal wear.
Returning the car early: you can return the car at any time. The lessor can then only claim the damages actually suffered, and must keep them to a minimum.
Guaranteed residual value: this type of contract, rare in Quebec, makes you cover part of the gap if the car is worth less than expected at the end. Your share is capped at 20% of the residual value. Most leases in Quebec are contracts with a purchase option instead.
In general, there is no cooling-off period to cancel a lease contract because you changed your mind. The only exception: a guaranteed residual value lease, which you can cancel at no charge within 2 days, except for a new vehicle you have already taken delivery of. Take the time to read everything before signing.
Pitfalls to avoid
Underestimating your mileage. Add up your real trips: work, visits, vacations. Better to pay for a few more kilometres up front than for a lot of excess kilometres on return.
Financing over too long a term. An 84-month loan lowers the payment, but you risk owing more than the car is worth for several years.
Adding products to your financing without comparing them. Rustproofing, protection packages and warranties added to the loan also cost interest.
Comparing payments over different terms. Always bring it back to a total cost.
Frequently asked questions
Is leasing a car worth it?
It depends on how you use it. Over a long period, buying generally costs less, because you end up driving without a payment. Leasing becomes attractive if you change cars often and drive little.
What is the 20/4/10 rule?
It is a rule of thumb popularized in the United States for buying a car: a down payment of at least 20%, a loan of 4 years at most, and car expenses (payment, insurance, gas) under 10% of your gross income. It is demanding, but useful to avoid going into debt beyond the vehicle's value.
Can you get out of a lease early?
Yes. The law lets you return the car at any time; the lessor can then claim only the damages actually suffered, which is often a significant amount. Another option is a lease transfer: someone else takes over your contract, with the consent of the lessor, who cannot refuse without a serious reason.
Is it better to buy out your car at the end of the lease?
Compare the buyout price set in the contract with the vehicle's actual value at that time. If the car is worth more than the residual value, buying it out can be a good deal.
Compare real offers, lease and purchase
The best way to decide is to compare real offers for the car you want. As soon as it launches in Quebec, bolyd will help you do that: you will describe the vehicle and the deal type you are interested in, and dealers will reply with their offers. You will then compare leasing and buying on concrete figures, in one place.
To read these offers properly, see our guide How to compare dealer offers.
bolyd is coming soon to Quebec
Describe the vehicle you want and get offers from dealers. Leave your email to hear when we open.


